Institute Name : Location : State :
Click here to close this message

Discussion is expired. You can not join it or argue it.

Reservation...! should be there or not ?

Reservation in Professional Education should be there or not. Is it beneficial for society or somewhere somehow it is hurting economy and quality or services. Let's Discuss

discussion_total_members
Total Members: 6
total votes
Total Votes: 57
time_start.png
Satrted On: 14/03/2010 08:00
time_end
End on:31/05/2010 01:00
Yes.....! Reservation Must be there in system group flag

Yes.....! Reservation Must be there in system

 

total members in this group
2
total votes of group
53
52

hello all frnds, Reservation is the privilege which has given to the needy students. As far as concern India is not a developed country i.e. normally people not belongs from good financial background, so many students want to join well known institutions but they don't have that much money to spend there and even they can't able to arrange their mesh and lodging there. so we have to give them extra perk by which they can also fulfill their dream.

 

By veerkushwah I 4/3/2010 6:36:40 AM
1

But it should be based on their financial position and not should be based on their cast.. You can never allow people who are not eligible. Would you happy if a doctor who is not eligible operating on your relative...

 

By mahingupta I 4/11/2010 11:42:56 PM
Post Comment
No.....! There should be reservation group flag

No.....! There should be reservation

 

total members in this group
4
total votes of group
4
3

A student is having 40% in his 10th standard ( means he knows only 40% of things he has studied during his 10th ) Same student had 38% in his 12th science Standard ( means he knows only 38% of things he has studied during his 12th ) Now he is studying in Medical college and becomes doctor. Now he is practicing in some government hospital, And applying his 30% knowledge to save lives... so rubbish.. come on.. reservations should not allow people who is not eligible.

 

By mahingupta I 3/19/2010 12:05:38 AM
Post Comment
2

Its Quite obvious that you can not allow any one to get best available opportunity on the basis of their Caste. by doing so some one is not only demotivate "NORMAL" candidates but also creates dependency in Reserve category candidates. Dr. B R Ambedkar asked for Equality not reservation I Do not believe in reservation policy, It simpily hurting India's Growth (Quality, Service and Status too)

 

By arun163 I 3/19/2010 12:20:15 AM
0

Cant agree more !!!

 

By mahingupta I 3/22/2010 3:43:51 AM
Post Comment
0

Cant agree more !!! :)

 

By mahingupta I 3/22/2010 3:31:31 AM
Post Comment
0

1stTIME- EVEN GOD DOESN'T DISCRIMINATE WITH PEOPLE ON THE BASIS OF THEIR CASTE WHILE GIVING THEM WIT AND OTHER NATURAL TALENTS..INTELLIGENCY AND OTHER TALENTS ARE NOT HERITAGE OF ANY PARTICULAR CASTE OR GENDER.SO I DO THINK THAT THERE SHOULD BE NO RESERVATION ON CASTE OR GENDER BASIS. 2ndTIME -THERE IS NO NEED TO GIVE RESERVATION EVEN TO ECONOMICALLY BACKWARD PEOPLE.IN PLACE OF GIVING RESERVATION TO ANYONE IN PROFESSIONAL EDUCATION WE CAN START PROVIDING MERIT BASED SCHOLARSHIPS TO POOR STUDENTS AT A PROPER STAGE WHICH IS TO PROVIDE SCHOLARSHIPS JUST AFTER 10th STANDARD. 3rd TIME-A PERSON WHO IS ONCE BENIFITTED BY RESERVATION AND IS ABLE TO PROVIDE BETTER MEANS OF EDUCATION TO HIS OWN CHILDREN THEN THEIR IS HIGHER PROBABLITY THAT AGAIN HIS OWN CHILDREN WILL BE BENIFITTED BY RESERVATION DUE TO HAVING BETTER MEANS OF EDUCATION THAN OTHER CHILDREN OF HIS CAST WHO DUE TO POR FINANCIAL CONDITION CAN'T HAVE PROPER MEANS OF EDUCATION. 4th TIME-SO AS I SAID LAST TIME RESERVATION AND IT'S BENEFIT BECOME HERITAGE OF OF SOME PARTICULAR PEOPLE IN A CASTE WHO ARE FINANCIALLY CAPABLE WHILE OTHER BACKWARD PEOPLE AND THEIR CHILDREN IN THAT CASTE REMAIN DEPRIVED OF BENEFITS OF RESERVATION.SO NOT RESERVATION BUT MERIT BASED SCHOLARSHIPS TO POOR STUDENTS OF ALL CASTES IS A BETTER OPTION TO BRING EQUALITY AND JUSTICE TO TALENTED BUT POOR STUDENTS. 5th TIME-EVEN IF WE THINK ACCORDING TO GLOBAL PROSPECTIVE TODAY WHAT OUR NATION NEEDS TO COMPETE WITH OTHER COUNTRIES LIKE U.S.A.,U.K.,AUSTRALIA,CHINA ETC. IN ANY FIELD THEN THE FOREMOST THING WHICH COMES TO MY MIND IS OUR MANPOWER WHICH MUST BE HIGHLY SKILLED AND TALENTED AND IT CAN BE POSSIBLE ONLY WHEN WE PROVIDE MERIT BASED SCHOLARSHIPS TO POOR BUT TALENTED STUDENTS(VIKRAM MAHESHWARI-1st AND PERHAPS LAST VIEW ON THIS FORUM.)

 

By I 5/18/2010 9:41:04 AM
Post Comment
-1

Very well said.

 

By mahingupta I 5/20/2010 3:52:49 AM
Post Comment
About mbagdpi.com
www.mbagdpi.com is promoted by DRONACHARYA Group. We are one of largest network of Admission & Career Consultants in India. We are working as Local Counseling centre for various B Schools/MBA Colleges/Management Institute in India. Most of our Associated Institutes are located in Pune, Delhi-NCR, Mumbai, Banglore, Ahmedabad, Hyderabad, Jaipur, Indore and other cities. Students who are looking for MBA related information such as How to apply for MBA, Institutes, Admission Procedure, Placements, Faculties, Facilities, Fees Structure, Syllabus, Total cost (Cost of living + Course fees), UGC/AICTE/DEC Approved Institutes, MBA/PGDM/PGP Course and Scope, Suitable Entrance Exam (CAT, MAT, XAT, IBSAT, SNAP, IIFT, FMS, NMAT, MHCET, eCATINDIA or other state level exams). Register yourself for anything about MBA/PGDM/PGP.